A Love for the Game: The Cornhole Addicts Journey

Why I stayed independent and what it cost me

A love for the game of cornhole

Where my love for the game started

I started Cornhole Addicts out of a simple love for the game and to build the biggest cornhole resource on the web. That’s really the whole reason.

I saw an an opportunity to offer something no one else was doing. While players often had to wait for bags to be made and shipped directly from manufacturers, I kept bags in stock and ready to go. In many cases, I could get bags into players’ hands faster than the bag makers themselves! That was something that set Cornhole Addicts apart from the very beginning.

From day one I wanted it to be more than a store. I wanted it to be somewhere you could find a new manufacturer you’d never heard of, read about a pro you’d only seen on a bracket, and feel like part of something bigger. I wanted to give the small bag makers the same shot as the big names, because they had the same love for the game I did.

Growing with the sport

As competitive cornhole took off, so did we. I didn’t make most of what we sold. What I did was bring a lot of different manufacturers together so players had real choices, and then work hard to get people to the site. I spent nights on SEO, content and social media. Slowly, Cornhole Addicts became a name people recognized, a place where players could share their love for the game.

The part I’m proudest of is the players. Their love for the game is what makes this sport special. I started writing profiles so fans could get to know the people behind the names. That turned into sponsoring players outright. I didn’t only focus on Pro players, I focused on the non-pro players just looking for a shot! I helped with travel, entry fees, apparel and equipment. For a small business, that was a real commitment. But I believed that if you take care of the players, you take care of the sport, and the sport takes care of you.

The offer

At some point, the American Cornhole League took notice of what I was building with Cornhole Addicts. I honestly believe they saw my growing business as a potential threat. What started as discussions about working together quickly turned into something much bigger. Thy wanted a 50% ownership stake in Cornhole Addicts, leaving me and a business partner, they selected, to split the remaining 50%.

In other words, I would go from owning 100% of the company I had built from the ground up to sharing just half of it with someone I hadn’t chosen. And with them holding 50%, they would have significant influence over the future direction of my business. It was flattering but after a lot of thought, I decided to stay independent.

I didn’t see that as walking away from the ACL. I kept promoting their events and sponsoring their players. I figured we shared a love for the game and wanted the same thing, which was for cornhole to grow. Looking back, I think that decision changed the relationship more than I realized at the time.

When things changed

A couple of years later, I started hearing from manufacturers I worked with. They were worried. A new league policy on co-branding had come out, and Cornhole Addicts had been named in it! Some of them weren’t sure they could keep selling to me at all.

I tried to fix it right away. I offered to change what I carried, I asked to be approved, and I reached out to league leadership directly. What came back felt personal, and it caught me completely off guard. I remember telling them that ever since I said no to the buyout, I’d felt like I was being pushed out. I wasn’t trying to start a fight. I was trying to save my business.

Then it reached my players. Some of the guys I sponsored were told, or at least came away believing, that they needed to cut ties with me to stay in good standing. One of them told me he didn’t want to, but he felt he had no choice. I understood. He had a career to protect. But it hurt, because those relationships were never just advertising to me. They were built on a shared love for the game.

The hardest stretch

Not long after that, the manufacturers I’d been buying from stopped supplying me. For an online store built on selection, that’s about as bad as it gets. Customers came to us for the brands they loved, and suddenly I couldn’t promise those brands would be there. A few suppliers came back eventually, and I’m grateful to them. But by then a lot of customers had found somewhere else to shop, and people don’t always come back.

The business today is a fraction of what it was at its peak. I know some of that is the market, since the whole sport has changed since the boom years. But I don’t believe that explains all of it.

The money is only part of it. What I really lost was momentum, and relationships I’d spent years building. It’s hard to describe watching the things that made your business work disappear one by one, while you’re still showing up every day trying to hold it together. Through all of it, my love for the game never went away.

Build on Ground You Control

What I’ve learned

I don’t think a league should have no rules. Every sport needs standards, and the ACL has every right to protect its brand. What I still wonder about is how those rules were applied to me, and whether things would have gone differently if I’d said yes to that offer. I can’t prove the answer. I just know the question has never gone away.

The biggest lesson I took from all this is simple. If your business depends on someone else’s approval, you don’t fully own it, no matter whose name is on the door. I’d tell any independent seller, manufacturer or content creator in this sport to build on ground you control.

Cornhole Addicts isn’t what it used to be. But I’m still here, and my love for the game is as strong as ever. I still believe in the players, the small shops, and the people who keep this sport going one tournament at a time. The work I put in was real, and so were the relationships.

Thanks for reading, and thanks to everyone who has stuck with us. You and your love for the game are the reason I’m still doing this.

— David Abate, Founder, Cornhole Addicts

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top